Taking off eye makeup with just regular soap and water doesn’t cut it, so a great eye makeup remover is a must. The first one I tried (as a suggestion from my mom) was Lancome’s BI-FACIL. Eye makeup removal with this is a snap–I usually put some on a q-tip after shaking the bottle to mix the 2 solutions, and everything comes off in one swipe. However at $26.00 (4.2 oz.), it wasn’t always in my budget.

Next up, I tried Neutrogena’s Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover. It caught my eye because just like Lancome’s BI-FACIL, it had 2 solutions that needed to be shaken before use.  The $7.99 (5.5 oz.) price tag didn’t hurt either! I found that Neutrogena’s Oil-Free Makeup Remover worked just as well as the BI-FACIL.

Now last night, I was about to pick up another bottle of Neutrogena, when I noticed the CVS brand Oil-Free Make-Up Remover right next to it. Since it looked very similar to Neutrogena, I decided to give it a whirl since it was $5.99 (6.4 oz.). And to my surprise, it worked just as well as the Neutrogena and Lancome.

CVS Oil Free Make-Up Remover is the clear winner here with a great product at a low price.